Environmental Controls: Copying the Clouds

A new scrubber technology solves submicron particulate pollution by copying an idea from nature.

The new technology has been implemented and proven at a number of facilities.
The collection of particulate under 1 micron has most often been achieved in the glass and ceramic industries using wet or dry electrostatic precipitators (ESPs). Venturi systems, diffusion candles and baghouses are also in use. However, such equipment has historically been expensive to buy and maintain and often requires a great deal of energy to operate. As a result, particulate collectors have become an Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) mandated, non-value-added expenditure that manufacturers of glass and ceramics, like the rest of industry, love to hate.

Recently, a new scrubber system* has been developed that features low operating costs, low energy consumption, and the ability to simultaneously handle both submicron particulate and hazardous fumes. The technology, which is based on the natural principle of cloud formation, has been implemented and proven at several major fiber optics manufacturing facilities, as well as other facilities generating submicron particulate in North America and Europe. The system has been shown to be 99%+ efficient for the collection of all types of particulate above 0.1 micron.

Principle of Operation

The idea for the new technology originated with a study of thunderstorms. “The process of lightning begins with an electrically charged raindrop,” said Clyde Richards, the technology’s inventor. “The water droplet becomes distorted by a charge from the cloud’s electric field. Electrical discharge starts, and that’s what triggers lightning. The electrical charge is an important part of the process, and a key component in the way rain cleans the air.

“Clouds are formed when water condenses on small particles of dust, or salt. Those particles naturally coagulate with larger ones—the phenomena is called Brownian motion—but in nature, the process is only about 1% efficient. The key to collecting particulate efficiently is to improve upon the action of the cloud: to ‘grow’ particulates by increasing humidity.

“At 80% relative humidity, for example, a particle that was originally .01 micron will, in seconds, double in size. At 100% humidity, it will grow to about .05 microns. Now, take it to 101% relative humidity—the point of slight super-saturation—and that particle becomes easily removable from a gas flow.”

Richards believed a technology could be developed that would use these principles to collect “earthbound” particulate. Over a 12-year period, his company, Atmospheric Physics Inc., researched and tested dozens of techniques to create the water droplet, particulate and electrical charge combination that would most efficiently allow particulate to be collected. The result was the new scrubber system, now licensed and distributed by Tri-Mer Corp.

Inside the scrubber’s collection chamber, billions of droplets are formed and electrically charged, causing droplets and uncharged particles to move continuously in relation to each other. The fact that particles are not charged is an important distinction, because the corona discharge used by ESP devices to drive particulate to a grounding plate consumes large amounts of energy. In fact, the new scrubber operates at barely 1% of the total energy required by an ESP for the same task. The new scrubber’s primary charge modules require just 600 watts of power, compared to the level of a typical electrostatic precipitator power draw of 60,000 watts or more.

With the new scrubber, as any particle passes between 10 and 20 microns of a water droplet, electrical attraction causes the particles to enter the water droplets. Each water droplet therefore becomes a “collector” of thousands of particles, constantly re-energizing with each pass through the system. Since the charged droplets are the collectors, there is no need for fibrous filters, collector plates, Venturi throats, layered pads, bags or cartridges. A schematic of the new scrubber system is shown in Figure 1.

Additional Benefits

In addition to lower energy requirements and fewer operating components, the new scrubber also offers three other primary benefits. First, the system requires a total operating pressure drop of .75 in. water gauge (w.g.) per stage—a fraction of that required by traditional particulate collection devices. In comparison, Venturi systems typically require 40 to 70 in. of pressure drop, while diffusion candles typically require 16 to 20 in. What makes the low pressure requirement possible for the new scrubber is a design that is void of interferences, a design that allows the cloud to form, as it does in the sky. The chamber of the new scrubber actually generates zero pressure; the .75-in. w.g. is generated by the mist eliminator droplet remover and connecting duct. This low pressure drop immediately—and substantially—reduces the costs of operating the fan.

Second, in cases where particulate is below 0.1 micron in size, a super-saturation section, interfaced into the system’s preconditioning chamber, is included in the system design. This facilitates the collection of particulate as small as 0.01 microns by allowing the particles to “grow” to a size that allows the scrubber to work successfully in ranges not possible with other technologies.

Third, the new scrubber has flexibility of application. It is alone in its ability to collect both soluble and insoluble particulate, and in its ability to scrub corrosive fumes, gases and odors simultaneously with particulate. The system can easily scrub 100 ppm of HCl to below 1 ppm, for instance, while collecting ammonium chloride, ammonium nitrate or other particulate matter, including silica dioxide and lead oxide. The system can also interface with applications requiring the reduction of SO2, Cl2, NH3, sulfuric acid, fluorine, and other gaseous emissions, which can eliminate the need for packed bed scrubbers. Due to its low pressure drop, the system can also act as a tail gas scrubber. Manufacturers can also incorporate the new scrubber with other selective catalytic reduction NOx removal systems.

The most advantageous particle size distribution for a scrubber unit is between 0.1 and 5 microns, but the system can also handle particulate hundreds of microns in size. Removal efficiencies of 99% and higher for particulate from 0.1 micron and above are achievable. The system handles inlet grain loadings in excess of 1.5 grains per dry standard cu. ft. (dscf), reducing loads to below 0.015 grains per dscf. Lower outputs are also possible, depending on site permit requirements.

Meeting Environmental Regulations

Environmental regulations are likely to become more stringent in the near future as the Environmental Protection Agency and other government agencies and organizations try to crack down on industrial emissions, including particulate matter. Companies that are proactive in their efforts to reduce their emissions will be able to focus more attention on their manufacturing efforts—rather than their compliance efforts—when new regulations go into effect. Additionally, implementing technologies with low energy and maintenance requirements can help ensure that compliance is achieved with the least possible impact on a company’s bottom line.

For More Information

For more information about the Cloud Chamber Scrubber and other scrubber technologies, contact Tri-Mer Corp., 1400 Monroe St. Owosso, MI 48867; (989) 723-7838; fax (989) 723-7844.

*The Cloud Chamber Scrubber™ (CCS™), supplied by Tri-Mer Corp., Owosso, Mich.


Did you enjoy this article? Click here to subscribe to Ceramic Industry Magazine.

You must login or register in order to post a comment.



Image Galleries

2015 Ceramics Expo

Snapshots from the 2015 Ceramics Expo, April 28-30, Cleveland, Ohio. Posted: May 14, 2015.


Ceramics Expo podcast
Editor Susan Sutton discusses the upcoming Ceramics Expo with event director Adam Moore.
More Podcasts

Ceramic Industry Magazine

CI May 2015 cover

2015 May

Our May issue covers bulk batching, pneumatic conveyors, high-temperature furnaces and more! Be sure to check it out today.

Table Of Contents Subscribe

Daily News

We know where you find the latest ceramic industry news (ahem), but where do you catch up on the rest of your daily news?
View Results Poll Archive


M:\General Shared\__AEC Store Katie Z\AEC Store\Images\Ceramics Industry\handbook of advanced ceramics.gif
Handbook of Advanced Ceramics Machining

Ceramics, with their unique properties and diverse applications, hold the potential to revolutionize many industries, including automotive and semiconductors.

More Products

Clear Seas Research

Clear Seas ResearchWith access to over one million professionals and more than 60 industry-specific publications,Clear Seas Research offers relevant insights from those who know your industry best. Let us customize a market research solution that exceeds your marketing goals.


facebook_40px twitter_40px  youtube_40pxlinkedin_40google+ icon 40px


CI Data Book July 2012

Ceramic Industry's Directories including Components, Equipment Digest, Services, Data Book & Buyers Guide, Materials Handbook and much more!