Better Refractories through Nanotechnology
At low temperatures, the CAC materials are very dense and have very low permeabilities. As the refractory is heated, the physical water is first driven off, followed by the chemically bonded hydrated water. Because several hydration phases are present, the complete dehydration process occurs over a broad temperature range (410 to 1148°F). As each of these phases gives up its chemically bonded water, bonding strength decreases, and permeability and porosity increase until all water has been removed.
Permeability and PorosityFigure 1 shows the porosity as a function of temperature for two similar cement and colloidal silica bonded castables. The porosity of the cement bonded castable increases as chemically bonded water is released over a broad temperature range. At high temperatures, the porosity can become very high and leave the refractory more prone to gas and slag attack. With colloidal silica bonded refractories, once the physical water has been removed, the porosity remains relatively constant to much higher temperatures. The lower porosity at intermediate temperatures leaves the colloidal silica bonded refractory more resistant to oxidation, gas attack and slag attack.
Water ReleaseThe distinctly different bond nature of cement and colloidal silica bonded refractories also produces a significantly different drying behavior. Due to the numerous hydration phases present in cement bonded castables, the water is released in stages at various temperatures. Since the water in the colloidal silica bonded refractory is not chemically bonded, it is free to be released at low temperatures. In a comparison of the water release from both a cement and a colloidal silica bonded matrix paste, more than 95% of the water was removed from the colloidal silica bonded material at only 230°F. Additional firings to higher temperatures were required to remove a comparable amount of water from the cement bonded material.
Likewise, Figure 3 illustrates the drying rates of two similar cement and colloidal silica bonded castables. At moderate temperatures, the colloidal silica bonded material releases nearly all of its contained water in only a couple of hours, whereas the cement bonded material releases less than 50% of its water in the same amount of time. Even after longer time periods, significant water remains in the cement bonded material, and it must be heated to much higher temperatures to remove this contained water. This is due to both the presence of hydrated water phases as well as low permeability values.
For colloidal silica bonded refractories, the high drying rates and initial permeabilities result in linings that are much less susceptible to steam spalling problems. The resulting dryout schedules tend to be much quicker, allowing for faster vessel turnaround. In some cases, the drying times can be cut in half or more using colloidal silica bonded refractories.
StrengthCement bonded materials often have greater initial strengths than colloidal silica bonded materials due to the hydraulic bond. However, CAC materials lose this strength as dehydration takes place. A cold modulus of rupture test showed a dip in the strength curve at about 1000°F for a cement bonded material due to a hydration phase loss and the associated bonding loss. Although the colloidal silica bonded product showed a lower initial strength, it showed a good progression in strength development and quickly equaled the cement bonded material at moderate temperatures (<1000°F).
At elevated temperatures, the strength differences become more dramatic. Figure 4 shows the hot strength values of colloidal silica bonded and similar cement bonded castables. Low-melting-temperature CaO-Al2O3-SiO2 phases associated with CAC castables are responsible for liquid phase formation at the indicated temperatures and the resulting lower hot strengths. Because the colloidal silica bonded materials are CaO-free, they do not generate these low melting phases and typically exhibit higher hot strengths-which results in better in-service erosion resistance for these materials.
Thermal Shock ResistanceGlassy phase formation and volume instability associated with CAC castables often cause degradation of properties upon thermal cycling. In most systems, colloidal silica bonded products have been shown to be superior in cycling applications. Figure 5 shows the strength loss of a CAC castable and a similar colloidal silica bonded pumpable material. After only a few cycles, the CAC material shows a loss of over 85% of its initial strength, while the colloidal silica bonded material loses strength much more slowly and at a steady, predictable rate.
Dependence on Installation ParametersColloidal silica bonded materials have proven to be much less dependent on installation variables than CAC refractories. In a test to determine the relative effects of increasing the moisture content in both a CAC castable and a colloidal silica bonded pumpable refractory, the CAC material exhibited a significant drop in strength when the moisture added was increased by even just small amounts. The colloidal silica bonded material was less affected by changes in moisture addition, and only changed slightly in strength with a higher liquid content.
Oxidation ResistanceCarbon additions to refractories can significantly reduce the wettability of slags and metals to the refractory and result in reduced corrosive attack. For this reason, many companies add extra carbon to the refractory material. However, carbon has a tendency to oxidize in certain environments. In the short term, the retained carbon may be greater, but in the long term the refractory body will become more and more porous because of the large amounts of carbon that are oxidized. Higher porosity allows oxygen to reach the refractory carbon at a much higher rate than in a low porosity material, and eventually the refractory will lose its integrity due to complete oxidation.
Acid ResistanceMagneco/Metrel studies have shown that cement bonded castables show significant attack and degradation in the presence of hydrochloric acid and sulfuric acid unless they are adequately heat treated. Unfortunately, some applications cannot withstand such temperatures. For instance, in certain pickling tank applications, a rubber lining is used at the refractory cold face. Firing the refractory to high temperatures would result in melting and breakdown of the rubber lining. These studies have also shown that colloidal silica bonded pumpable materials stand up well to acids under all firing conditions. When both cement bonded and colloidal silica bonded refractories were exposed to sulfuric acid, degradation in the cement bonded refractories was rapid, whereas the colloidal silica bonded material showed no attack.
Measurements of weight loss as a function of acid exposure indicate the resilience of colloidal silica bonded materials to acid. Figure 8 indicates that although 90% alumina cement bonded castables show rapid weight losses in the presence of sulfuric acid, colloidal silica bonded materials show minimal losses.
Bonding to Existing MaterialThe ultra-fine nature of the colloidal silica binder and the nature of the siloxane bond formation allows for excellent bonding to existing refractory linings. The nanometer-sized (10-9 meter) particles are much finer than the typical micron-sized (10-6 meter) cement particles and more easily penetrate the surface of existing linings. Siloxane bonds can then form and penetrate into the surface material of the lining. Cement bonds do not extend into the refractory lining, but only allow for a physical interlocking with voids or cracks in the surface. Figure 9 illustrates the excellent bond of a colloidal silica bonded castable to another refractory material.
Enhanced PerformanceColloidal silica bonded refractories have exhibited excellent flow behavior, hot strength, thermal shock resistance, oxidation and acid resistance, and bond strength in a variety of applications. With these new materials, manufacturers in the ceramic, glass and related industries have a new alternative for enhancing the performance of their thermal processing operation.
For more information about colloidal silica bonded refractories, contact Magneco/Metrel, Inc., 223 Interstate Rd., Addison, IL 60101; (630) 543-6660; fax (630) 543-1479; or visit www.magnecometrel.com.
SIDEBAR: Castables, Pumpables and ShotcretingPrecast Shape and Castable Refractories
The new pumpable refractory materials can also be used as castables for shape production. The liquid colloidal silica binder is added to the dry aggregate, and setting agent additions in the dry aggregate cause the castable to set at a controlled rate. Because of the materials' self-leveling properties, minimal vibration is usually applied in casting into molds. No hydrated cement phases are involved, so complete drying of shapes can be accomplished at much lower temperatures than cement based shapes and without the risk of explosive spalling. Shapes can range from a few pounds to several tons.
The colloidal silica bonded pumpable materials can be easily placed via concrete pumping equipment. The self-leveling characteristics of these materials allow placement without the aid of vibration. The ability to pump and the easy dryout characteristics allow for very short turnaround times, reducing costly losses in production and equipment availability.
Shotcrete or "spray gunned" materials were developed to remove some of the inconsistencies of dry gunned materials. The expected advantages include:
- Minimal or no dust
- Minimal rebound
- Homogeneously mixed materials
- Reduction of laminations
- Significantly improved properties
- Castable properties without the need of a form
Shotcrete materials are wet mixed like normal pumpables and pushed through a hose or pipe using a pump. At the hose end a set accelerant is injected via a high-pressure air stream, and the air stream forces the material out through a nozzle and at a target. The accelerant causes the material to thicken, losing flowability in a matter of seconds rather than hours, as in the case of normal pumpables. The key to a good shotcrete material is to have the proper accelerant. The accelerant needs to:
- Cause a fast thickening of the pumpable material
- Have low sensitivity to concentration variations
- Retain a high plasticity of the pumpable material
- Be adaptable to various compositions
- Preserve the properties of the pumpable material
The ideal situation is of a fast flocculation so that the pumpable material exhibits a plastic consistency over a broad accelerant concentration range. This allows for good packing and densification of the shotcrete material. The primary advantage is the ability to install a castable product in areas otherwise restricted to gun mixes, such as hot inaccessible areas or areas that are difficult or too time consuming to form.