- THE MAGAZINE
- Advertiser Index
- Raw & Manufactured Materials Overview
- Classifieds & Services Marketplace
- Buyers' Connection
- List Rental
- Market Trends
- Material Properties Charts
- Custom Content & Marketing Services
- CI Top 10 Advanced Ceramic Manufacturers
- Virtual Supplier Brochures
Selling a privately held middle market company is more of an art than a science. (Middle market deals are defined as those with transaction prices in the range from $2 million-$250 million.) Even experienced professionals realize that there are few sources of empirical data to use in pricing a middle market deal. The available information is usually sparse and superficial, and therefore of limited use in determining a transaction price. In addition, the procedures to use to sell or value a middle market company, the valuation multiple to apply, the appropriate transaction structure and the likely events that will occur after a closing are usually substantially different for middle market deals than for the more publicized major public deals. Due to the uniqueness and complexity of middle market deals and the lack of meaningful information on the subject, it is essential to follow seven critical rules to be successful in the sale of your company:
1. Obtain a principally all-cash deal.
2. Retain a competent acquisition consulting/investment banking firm (advisory firm).
3. Define your expected transaction price before going to market.
4. Demand minimal exposure to post-closing issues and liabilities arising from the definitive purchase agreement.
5. Accept that negotiations tend to be adversarial.
6. Be patient.
7. Divulge proprietary information only at the appropriate time.
Obtain A Principally All-Cash DealIn an acquisition, as in business, you are trying to maximize both price and risk. There is no better way to accomplish the latter than by doing a principally all-cash deal. There are only two reasons why an acquirer wants a seller to accept notes:
- There is a lack of bank or institutional financing available to the acquirer, or it is available at an interest rate much higher than they are willing to give the seller.
- Notes can be an easy conduit for an acquirer to collect for alleged seller breaches of representations and warranties. This could necessitate a seller pursuing litigation to collect on their notes.
In a similar vein, I would almost never consider a deal with a contingent price factor, unless the contingency portion is in excess of my expected transaction price. There is no way to protect the seller's ability to meet the contingency goals without unreasonably restricting the actions of the acquirer after the deal.
Retain a Competent Acquisition Consulting FirmA seller should use an advisory firm to guide and direct them through the entire process. This includes planning the sale, the valuation, the development of an enticing offering circular, the search for a synergistic acquirer, and the conduct and control of all negotiations leading to a closing. The advisory firm should use a personalized, tailored approach that encompasses a review of all aspects of the seller's business foundation and niche. Such review far transcends a mere analysis of the financial statements, which only represents a small part of the review.
The advisory firm should be committed to closing a sale only after an aggressive premium price has been obtained. It should have a reputation that the seller's best interest is the only factor that dictates an acceptable deal. The advisor must also have a thorough understanding of the economic implications of the legal issues that are likely to arise in negotiating the definitive purchase agreement, and it should control all negotiations with the attorneys working under its guidance. In a middle market deal, it is usually preferable to use an advisory firm with entrepreneurial flair, as it often will have a similar background and psychological make-up to the selling owner. The firm will understand the feelings that the seller will be dealing with during the acquisition process. Consequently, it can provide the emotional support that most sellers find beneficial at this time. As the negotiations leading to the closing are the most critical phase of an acquisition, the seller wants an advisor that is a strong-willed, articulate and persuasive negotiator. An advisor with these skills, approach and characteristics is necessary for a seller to obtain a premium price.
Define Your Expected Transaction PriceAcquirers are trying to steal your company-that is how the capitalist system works. Unfortunately, the acquirer is usually larger, has greater resources, and is more knowledgeable about acquisitions. However, sophisticated, hard-working sellers can level the playing field.
Prior to going to market, a seller should have its advisory firm comprehensively evaluate all facets of the company's business foundation. Its major future opportunities and risks should be determined, evaluated and quantified. When this process is completed, the seller and its advisory firm should feel that their knowledge of the company's future earnings potential is greater than an acquirer's. The determinant of a company's value will be its expected future earnings/EBITDA and the risk of achieving those earnings/EBITDA. This value will be impacted by both short-term future earnings potential and long-term growth factors. The stability of the business foundation will have an impact on the multiple applied to the company's earnings/EBITDA. Depending on synergistic benefits, internal corporate needs and differing perceptions of valuation factors, most prospective acquirers will see a company's value differently but within a price range of +/-10-15% of an average market price.
Be aggressive in your pricing expectations, and demand a realistic premium price. Remember you only sell your company to one buyer. You are not trying to get five acquirers to pay a normalized price; your objective is for one acquirer to pay a premium price. Once your pricing expectations are set, be confident and firm in your position, since most acquirers will try to convince you of the exorbitance of your pricing position.
Demand Minimal Exposure to Post-Closing Issues and LiabilitiesLarge acquirers are used to shifting most deal risks to the seller. Although this is the norm, it could be injurious to your economic health. After a company is sold, the owner has no upside. Correspondingly, the owner should have no downside risk for occurrences that become known after the deal closes.
To ensure a more equitable sharing of deal risk between seller and buyer, a seller should want the majority of its representations and warranties to be limited to "seller's knowledge." A few representations and warranties normally require a higher standard of seller guarantee. However, in these cases, the seller usually is aware if there is a problem prior to the deal closing and should have limited risk of the unknown. An acquirer will strongly contest the "seller's knowledge" position, but a seller should not relent unless the deal price compensates them for the added risk.
Accept that Negotiations Tend to be AdversarialNegotiations are a test of wills-a battle for control. By their very nature, negotiations are a confrontational process, and a seller should accept that. In most corporate sales, the seller is usually much smaller and less knowledgeable about acquisitions than the buyer. Correspondingly, buyers are used to deals being priced the way they want. If an acquirer is forced to pay a price in excess of their target price, it will usually require difficult and adversarial negotiations before an acquirer acquiesces. If negotiations go smoothly and amicably, the acquirer is usually obtaining their price. Rarely would this represent a premium price to the seller. Therefore, accept the confrontational nature of negotiations, as this is normally essential if a seller is to get a good deal.
Be PatientIf a seller is to be successful, patience must usually be demonstrated throughout the acquisition process. Patience should not be confused with lethargy. Instead, it represents the seasoned market response when a slow pace works to a seller's advantage. If a seller has thoroughly evaluated all factors surrounding the sale, being patient should be easy. Patience is usually a byproduct of confidence in the validity of one's position. A patient seller usually produces anxiety in an acquirer. As an acquirer should never be aware of the full dynamics of the overall sale process, a patient seller usually is interpreted as one that has many attractive alternatives. This should tend to make the acquirer more flexible in negotiations.
Divulge Proprietary Information Only at the Appropriate TimeAs a general rule, it is advisable not to consider customers, competitors or suppliers as a potential acquirer. If unique or compelling circumstances mandate that such prospects be pursued, they must be approached much more cautiously than when working with a typical acquirer. When this type of prospect is solicited, it is often advisable to significantly strengthen the confidentiality agreement one or more of the following ways:
- Limit the acquirer's right to solicit the employees and/or customers of the selling company in the future.
- Limit the detailed information provided the acquirer at the initial stage of the process.
- Require much more detailed financial and business information about the acquirer at the initial stage than is normally obtained.
- Information pertinent to sales levels or pricing specifics for individual customers or products.
- Purchase or production costs for specific products or customers.
- Specific pricing strategies by product, volume or other pertinent factors.
- Specific future operating courses of action.